Ally Lewber’s Perfect Match finale did not exactly end with a quiet toast and a neat little relationship status card. During the May 27 season four finale, the reality star admitted that her time with costar Hashim Moore went further than she had initially told Jimmy Presnell.
What Hashim Moore told Jimmy Presnell
The reveal came when the cast gathered during the Netflix episode and Hashim, who appeared on Temptation Island, addressed Jimmy directly.
"I'm not sure exactly what Ally's told you, Jimmy, just in terms of our time together," Hashim said. "This is pretty uncomfortable for me, but just bro code... Me and Ally were physically intimate."
Jimmy, known from Love Is Blind, appeared to have been working with a much shorter version of events.
"She told me y'all kissed," he said.
Hashim did not spell out the details in front of everyone. Instead, he told Jimmy, "You guys just need to have a conversation." A restrained suggestion, considering the room had already become everyone’s least favorite group project.
The unseen footage added more context
After Hashim’s comment, Perfect Match showed previously unaired footage of Ally and Hashim in bed together under the covers.
"Poor Jimmy," Ally said from beneath the sheets. "I’m being crazy. I need to behave."
Hashim replied, "This is fun."
The clip made clear that the pair’s night together involved more than a brief kiss, setting up a tense exchange between Ally and Jimmy after the group discussion.
Ally said it was “just a little more”
Once Hashim’s admission was out, Ally whispered to Jimmy that she had done "just a little more" with Hashim than she had previously shared.
"It was really quick," she said. "I sucked his d--k for literally like 10 seconds. It was literally 10 seconds."
Ally, who announced in January 2025 that she and Vanderpump Rules costar James Kennedy had split following his domestic violence arrest, defended what happened by pointing to the show’s dating format and her understanding with Jimmy.
"We were open," she told him.
She also insisted, "I didn’t lie to you."
Jimmy’s reaction was measured, if not exactly thrilled
Jimmy had been matched with Ally only days earlier, and the two had already been intimate. On camera, he looked visibly stunned while taking in the new information.
Still, he kept his voice down. Instead, he described their connection as something the show had stress-tested.
"We have done things the right way by being open here, and we have put our relationship to the test in a way that maybe a lot of people here haven't," Jimmy said. "I'm gonna give her grace, because our story was a wild ride, and I wouldn't change a thing about it."
Neither Ally nor Jimmy has publicly clarified where they stand romantically since the finale aired. They have, however, appeared together in TikTok videos in recent weeks, which in reality TV terms is not a legal filing, but it is not nothing either.
